Battle of the Pop Charts

August 1979 versus August 2004

 

Let the Pulse Panel decide

 1 August 2004  4 August 1979 Pulse Panel Result 
1. Busted - Thunderbirds

By all accounts the film is complete travesty as is the fact that  they didn't just use the theme music from the original TV series. Ignoring that, this is quite an accomplished slice of power-pop from the thinking pre-pubescent's boy-band.

Boomtown Rats - I Don't Like Mondays

From a time when High School gun massacres were the sort of thing you could write pop songs about. Mr Geldof was obviously very pleased with himself for this but I didn't think it was clever then and it just sounds embarrassing now. 


Home Win.
2.  Streets - Dry Your Eyes

For all the critical acclaim this is one of those tracks (and the same is true of the album as a whole) that you really don't want to hear more than once. You wait all that time for a successful  British rap song and  when comes along you realise why it took so long.  

The Police - Can't Stand Losing You

Unlike the Boomtown Rats, the Police have finally acquired a bit of credibility  (that doesn't of course apply to solo Sting with his tantric sex nonsense). Perhaps if they'd sung about guns instead of girls their white-boy reggae wouldn't have provoked quite so much opprobrium from certain quarters.   


Away Win.
 

 

3.  Shapeshifters - Lola's Theme

A decent dance record gatecrashing the top of the chart. What is this, 1998 or something ? (However I'd recommend that you try and get hold of it in its original form rather than this 'radio-friendly' version).

The Dooleys - Wanted

To be honest what we really, really wanted was to forget we'd ever heard this. 

Pop trivia fact : The Dooleys are the largest UK family act to hit the charts. 

Home Win.
4. D12 - How Come

More lumbering, unimaginative dross from Eminem's side project. How come this can do so well when there are so many superior hip hop offerings out there.

Dave Edmunds - Girls Talk

A classic Costello-penned rocker, top tune, great lyrics from a time when those qualities carried some weight. An effortlessly easy vistory.

Away Win.
5. Rachel Stevens - Some Girls

Former S-Clubber goes off in an electro direction and the results are actually not that shabby.  Lacks a bit of oomph but 6 out of 10 for effort 

Abba - Angel Eyes / Voulez-Vous

The sound of the Swedish fab four treading water. A couple of album-fillers lumped together as a double A-side.  Two misses for the price of one.

Score Draw.
6. J-Kwon - Tipsy

A phat beat (as they say) but the rap sounds like the worst bits of several other recent records stuck together. Which it might well be for all I know.

Janet Kay - Silly Games

 A truly gorgeous slice of lovers rock. Sounds just as good a quarter of a century later. If you can't adore this you're past redemption pal.

Away Win.
 

 

7. Usher - Burn

A man who can do no wrong at the moment even when he produces soppy nonsense like this. Smoulders like damp J-cloth. Barry White must be spinning like a top. 

Tubeway Army - Are Friends Electric

Ridiculous undoubtedly but you have to admire the way that Gary Numan has surfed the waves of terminal uncoolness and landed safely on the shores of respectability.  

Away  Win.
 

 

8. O-Zone - Dragostea Din Tei

Now this is a bizarre one. Perhaps someone can explain how this differs from any number of failed Eurovision entries from the last few years, none of which have had a frog in a blender's chance of making the charts. 

The Knack - My Sharona

Laughably touted at the time as the forerunners of a US-style New Wave but disappeared faster than a Club Rep's dignity. This solitary UK hit was at least good enough not to be confused with a Eurovison song.

Away  Win.
9. Britney Spears - Everytime

After the surprising funkiness of 'Toxic' this is a disappointing venture into Celine Dion territory. Not that it matters though - a recording of a colonic irrigation would still have won this match-up.

Supertramp - Breakfast In America

Aaaaargh !

Home Win
10. Jamelia - See It In A Boy's Eyes

A typically polished noughties production job but the song lacks a bite. Give it a few months and you won't have a clue who did it or when.

Sparks - Beat The Clock

From the Mael brothers' second coming as European disco futurists.  If you're in the right mood it still sounds fantastic. If not it sounds like two cats fighting in a wheelie-bin.

Score Draw.

 

 

FINAL SCORE - 2004 - 4  1979 - 6

So a victory for the veterans this time around but then this was an usually good week as far as late Seventies chart-toppers go. And if the rules allowed for a minus score then Supertramp would definitely qualify. As always I'll leave you to draw your own conclusions based on the Pulse Panel's subjective decisions.

Back to Home Page

Battle Archives : 
March 2003 versus March 1978
 May 2002 versus May 1977
 May 2001 versus May 1976
October 2000 vs October 1975
Links :
http://www.yearsofgold.org.uk
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio1/chart/top40/